Conclusion: Our investigation revealed that human studies evaluating the efficacy of ED-S ingredients are limited and have yielded no definitive findings of the effects on ED. Patients considering ED-S use should receive appropriate counseling, given the prevalence of disingenuous reviews and the ready availability of Food and Drug Administration-approved drug therapies. Balasubramanian A, Thirumavalavan N, Srivatsav A, et al. An Analysis of Popular Online Erectile Dysfunction Supplements. J Sex Med 2019;16:843-852.
PubMed 31036522 ↗Horny Goat Weed
The short answer. People are split on Horny Goat Weed — 51% of 85 say it helped. It is most often used for libido: 75% of 65 reports say that improved. There is a moderate body of research — 3 meta-analyses and 0 trials.
From 217 mentions in total — the rest didn't say how it went and aren't counted.
What Horny Goat Weed does, according to users
Of the people who reported each effect, the share who said it got better.
4 more with fewer than 3 reports
What the research says
Systematic reviews and meta-analyses from PubMed, with their published conclusions.
At least one meta-analysis, or 5+ randomized controlled trials. The grade measures how much human research exists — read the conclusions below for what it found. 3 meta-analyses on PubMed ↗ · 0 randomized trials ↗
Conclusion: Based on these results, the presnet study suggested that icariin might possess substantial antiosteoporosis effect in ovariectomized rats. Safety studies and large randomized clinical trials are needed to further support possible clinical applications of icariin in postmenopausal women with osteoporosis.
PubMed 29208188 ↗Conclusion: Overall, 69% of ingredients in testosterone supplements and 52% of ingredients in ED supplements have published RCT evidence. Many male supplements claim to improve testosterone or ED parameters; however, there is limited evidence, which should be considered when counseling patients.
PubMed 32358510 ↗3 human trials on ClinicalTrials.gov test Horny Goat Weed — 3 completed. See all on ClinicalTrials.gov ↗
- Effects of Botanical Microglia Modulators in Gulf War Illness · Gulf War Illness · 2022
- Icariin to Prevent Corticosteroid-related Memory Changes · the Pharmacokinetic Profile of Icariin in Humans · 2016
- Study of Icariin for Bipolar Disorder and Co-Occurring Substance Use Disorders · Bipolar Disorder, Substance Use Disorder · 2015
Reports to the FDA
Adverse-event reports about supplements containing it, submitted to the US FDA by consumers and doctors.
29 reports name a product containing Horny Goat Weed (2005–2025); 14 involved hospitalization or worse. Most often reported:
- Heart rate increased · 5
- Dizziness · 4
- Headache · 4
- Nausea · 3
- Hypertension · 3
- Vomiting · 3
A report doesn't prove the supplement caused the problem — many products contain several ingredients, and these counts can't tell you how often it happens. Source: FDA CAERS ↗ · raw reports (openFDA) ↗.
What government agencies say
Official records from US, Canadian and EU regulators, each linked to its source.
1 recall of products named for Horny Goat Weed. Most recent:
- 2017-01-04 · Class II: Pursuant to a consent decree that prohibits the company and its owners for marketing dietary supplements until they, among other things, recall and destroy… record ↗
Class I = could cause serious harm; Class II = temporary or reversible harm; Class III = unlikely to cause harm. Recalls are of specific products and lots, not of the ingredient itself. All recalls (openFDA) ↗
LiverTox rates Horny Goat Weed E — an unlikely cause of liver injury. LiverTox entry ↗
Dosage people report
As stated by users — not a recommendation. Follow the label or your doctor.
Reported side effects
How often each side effect came up across all reports.
What users say
First-hand experiences, quoted verbatim. We show one positive and one negative where both exist.
“Lately I've been alternating days between black ginger and HGW and I really feel a difference in mood, libido and blood flow.”
“HGW is grand and all but it makes me sore and you're better off taking a proper pde-5.”
“List of things I've tried (some worked, but only for a few days and then never worked again)”
“ND 10% HGW. Better Blood flow and Vascularity. BG however, doesn’t make my chest itchy like HGW (flares my preexisting gyno)”
Top discussions (5)
- Hello. I was severely damaged by a common medication I took 6 years and 10 months ago. ↗
- My life got terribly ruined by an SSRI antidepressant I took for only about 25 days in July of 2019. Please give me something to help this I’m so desperate ↗
- Supplements for Insane libido ↗
- Viagra is CORRELATED with a decreased risk of Alzheimer's disease ↗
- My tested, tolerance resistant, heart healthy stack for mild ADHD ↗
Horny Goat Weed compared
Other options for libido
Sources
- User reports: 217 mentions in public discussions, quoted with a link to each discussion (e.g. this thread ↗).
- PubMed (US National Library of Medicine, NIH): meta-analyses ↗ · randomized trials ↗
- ClinicalTrials.gov (NIH): registered trials ↗
- FDA recalls ↗
- LiverTox (NIH) ↗
- US Food and Drug Administration: CAERS adverse-event reports ↗
User data from public discussions; research from PubMed. Information only, not medical advice — talk to a doctor before starting, stopping or combining anything. Data updated October 5, 2026. How we rate