PlainPill

How PlainPill works

Most supplement sites are either marketing or a literature review. We combine two sources that rarely meet: what thousands of real users report after trying something, and what controlled research has found. Both are shown side by side, with sources, so you can judge for yourself.

20,425
discussions analyzed
144,221
user reports
4,140
substances

1. Real-world user reports

We collect public discussions from the largest online communities about supplements, nootropics, biohacking and peptides — spanning more than fifteen years. A local filter keeps only discussions that mention a known substance; an AI analyst then reads each discussion and records, for every substance mentioned:

  • the verdict of that discussion — worked, didn't work, mixed, or unclear;
  • specific effects reported (sleep, focus, weight, mood…) and whether they improved, worsened or didn't change;
  • doses and schedules people state, side effects, and a short verbatim quote with a link to the source.

The analyst is instructed to record only what the text says: no invented effects, doses or quotes. Spelling variants ("mag glycinate", "magnesium bisglycinate") are merged into one entry.

2. "% helped" and how lists are ordered

The number we show is simple: of the people who said how it went, the share who say it helped. Mentions that don't state an outcome (about half of them) are not counted either way. It always comes with the number of reports and a confidence level — high (100+), medium (20–99) or few reports (under 20).

Lists are ordered by that share adjusted for sample size — technically, the lower bound of its 95% confidence interval. In practice: 83% from 600 people ranks above 92% from 26 people, because the first number is far more reliable. Goal rankings ("best for sleep") work the same way, using the reports about that specific effect. Headline rankings only include things with 20+ reports; smaller ones stay on the site, marked "few reports".

Habits and methods — exercise, sleep, diets, fasting — are rated the same way but listed separately on Habits & methods, so they don't crowd out supplement rankings.

Doses. We show doses users report for ordinary supplements, only when a number and unit are given. We never show doses for peptides, SARMs or prescription medications.

3. The research grade

For every substance with enough reports we search PubMed, the U.S. National Library of Medicine database, for meta-analyses and systematic reviews, and for randomized controlled trials in humans. We show the most relevant reviews with their published conclusions.

A
Strong research base
3+ meta-analyses or systematic reviews and 10+ randomized controlled trials in humans.
B
Moderate research base
At least one meta-analysis, or 5+ randomized controlled trials.
C
Limited research
1–4 randomized controlled trials, no meta-analysis yet.
D
No human trials found
No randomized controlled trials in humans found on PubMed.

The grade measures the depth of research, not its direction: a substance can have many meta-analyses that conclude it doesn't work. That's why every substance page shows the conclusions themselves.

4. What this can and can't tell you

  • User reports are anecdotes. Placebo, self-selection (people who had a strong reaction post more) and unverified claims all apply. Large numbers reduce noise; they don't remove bias.
  • Absence of research ≠ doesn't work, and lots of research ≠ works.
  • Doses shown are what people reported, not recommendations.
  • AI extraction makes occasional mistakes. Every quote links to its source so you can check.

5. Independence

Rankings contain no affiliate links and can't be bought. Sponsored placements exist to fund the site; they are always labelled "Sponsored", visually separated, and never change a score or a position.

Medical disclaimer

PlainPill is for information only and is not medical advice. Supplements, medications, peptides and SARMs can interact with each other and with health conditions. Talk to a doctor or pharmacist before starting, stopping or combining anything — especially if you are pregnant, nursing, under 18, or taking prescription medication. Peptides and SARMs listed here are generally not approved for human use as supplements, are banned in competitive sport and may be illegal to buy where you live.

Browse the rankings