PlainPill

Magnesium Glycinate vs Melatonin for sleep

Short answer: For sleep, more users report improvement with Magnesium Glycinate — 83% of 668 reports, versus 78% of 915 for Melatonin.

Magnesium Glycinate has 82 meta-analyses and 210 randomized trials on PubMed; Melatonin has 688 and 1,128.

Based on 1,693 reports about Magnesium Glycinate and 1,370 about Melatonin. Not medical advice.

Magnesium Glycinate
Supplement
Melatonin
Supplement
Users say it helped68%helped965 reports · high confidence42%helped726 reports · high confidence
Verdict
Mostly positive
Mixed
ResearchAResearch: StrongAResearch: Strong
Meta-analyses / RCTs82 / 210688 / 1,128
Mainly used for
Sleep
% reporting improvement
83% (668)78% (915)
Anxiety
% reporting improvement
81% (336)44% (16)
Mood
% reporting improvement
74% (103)32% (37)
Energy
% reporting improvement
66% (56)32% (25)
Focus
% reporting improvement
69% (54)38% (8)
Common side effectsdrowsiness, fatigue, vivid dreams, brain fogdrowsiness, vivid dreams, fatigue, depression
Typical dose reported200 mg / occasionally0.5 mg / bedtime
Magnesium Glycinate
Latest review conclusion

This review confirms that the quality of literature is substandard for physicians to make well-informed recommendations on usage of oral magnesium for older adults with insomnia. However, given that oral magnesium is very cheap and widely available, RCT evidence may support oral magnesium supplements (less than 1 g quantities given up to three times a day) for insomnia symptoms.

BMC Complement Med Ther, 2021 ↗
What a user said
“The brain fog started lifting. The constant low-grade anxiety that I had accepted as "normal" started to ease.”
Full Magnesium Glycinate profile →
Melatonin
Latest review conclusion

Overall, eszopiclone and lemborexant had a favorable profile, but eszopiclone might cause substantial adverse events and safety data on lemborexant were inconclusive. Doxepin, seltorexant, and zaleplon were well tolerated, but data on efficacy and other important outcomes were scarce and do not allow firm conclusions. Many licensed drugs (including benzodiazepines, daridorexant, suvorexant, and trazodone) can be effective in the acute treatment of insomnia but are associated with poor tolerability, or information about long-term effects is not available. Melatonin, ramelteon, and non-licensed

Lancet, 2022 ↗
What a user said
“I have taken it nightly for 19 years. Doses ranging from .1 to 10mg. Right now I take 3mg per night. It helps me sleep.”
Full Melatonin profile →

Related comparisons

Percentages come from first-hand user reports and are not clinical outcomes. Talk to a doctor before starting, stopping or combining anything. How we rate